⚠"
en | US
OBSERVE Magazine

Subscribe to our global magazine to hear our latest insights, opinions, and featured articles.

Peer-to-Peer Director Assessments: Building Better Boards Through Constructive Feedback

6 min read

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Peer assessments can strengthen board effectiveness and individual director contributions, but their success depends on trust, clarity of purpose and how feedback is delivered.

Board assessments are an established part of corporate governance, giving directors an opportunity to reflect on the effectiveness of the board, its committees and its leadership. Yet one dimension remains less common: direct peer feedback among individual directors.

Peer-to-peer assessments provide an opportunity to look beyond collective performance and consider individual contributions to board effectiveness. When thoughtfully designed, they can support director development, strengthen board culture and inform board composition. However, they also introduce sensitivities, particularly when feedback is perceived as a performance review rather than an opportunity for growth. Their purpose should be to strengthen individual contributions and overall board effectiveness, not simply measure performance.

To better understand how boards approach peer assessments, Odgers surveyed 40 directors serving on 90 public company boards across industries and company sizes, from early-stage organizations to companies generating $400 billion in revenue. The findings explore how commonly these assessments are used, how directors perceive their value and what boards should consider before introducing them.

An Emerging Practice, with Encouraging Results

Despite the growing emphasis on board effectiveness, formal peer-to-peer director assessments remain relatively uncommon. Of the 90 boards represented in the survey, just 29% had conducted them. The remaining 71% had not adopted a formal peer assessment process. A recent industry survey cited 49% of S&P 500 companies disclosing use of individual director assessments in their proxies.

Among the directors who had participated in such a process, however, the response was largely positive. Nearly three-quarters (73%) recommended the practice or found it valuable, while 12% did not recommend it and 15% reported neutral or mixed experiences.

These findings suggest that peer assessments can be valuable when well executed. Directors who viewed the process favorably cited opportunities to identify areas for personal growth, receive tailored coaching from board chairs and lead directors, foster more candid boardroom discussions and identify potential board refreshment needs.

Peer assessments can therefore complement traditional board evaluations by addressing a question that broader assessments may not fully answer: how effectively is each director contributing to the board’s collective work?

Enhancing Traditional Board Assessment

All boards represented in the survey employ some form of an assessment process. Annual evaluations typically examine the board, its committees and committee chairs, often through online questionnaires. Individual feedback may also emerge through open-ended responses or one-on-one conversations with the chair or lead director.

The distinction is that traditional board evaluations assess collective performance, while peer assessments focus on individual contributions, including how directors engage in discussion, challenge assumptions and support sound decision-making.

Rather than replacing existing practices, peer assessments can complement them, helping boards identify individual strengths and development opportunities that might otherwise go unaddressed.

The question is whether current assessment practices provide sufficient insight into individual director effectiveness.

Trust is the Foundation of Meaningful Feedback

For boards considering peer-to-peer assessments, the Directors we spoke to emphasized the importance of trust both leading up to and through the assessment process. 

Directors who had participated in peer assessments generally viewed them as an opportunity to improve performance. Interestingly, those who had not previously participated in a formal peer-to-peer assessment process, were more likely to perceive them as formal performance reviews with potentially punitive consequences.

This difference has practical implications. If directors believe the process is intended to be critical or build a case for removing a colleague, they may be less willing to provide candid feedback. The result can undermine the openness the process is intended to encourage.

Several respondents cautioned against using peer assessments to justify a director’s exit. While feedback may inform broader discussions about board composition and renewal, using the process to build a case against an individual risks eroding trust across the board.

Purpose and communication are therefore critical. Before introducing peer assessments, board leadership should explain why the process is being undertaken, what it is intended to achieve, and how feedback will be used. Directors should understand that the primary objective is to strengthen individual and collective effectiveness, not to create a punitive evaluation mechanism. 

This does not mean avoiding difficult feedback. The distinction lies in whether these concerns are addressed through a transparent, development-oriented process or one perceived as predetermined or adversarial.

Who Should Facilitate the Process?

The survey identified several approaches to peer assessments, from anonymous online questionnaires to interviews led by the board chair, lead director or other governance leaders. Some boards engage an external firm.

Each approach offers potential advantages, depending on the board’s culture, relationships and objectives.

An external facilitator may provide independence and help directors feel more comfortable sharing candid feedback. A third party can also bring structure, identify recurring themes and help ensure feedback is communicated consistently.

However, external facilitation does not guarantee a positive experience. Some respondents raised concerns that feedback had been diluted to preserve client relationships. These experiences highlight the importance of selecting a facilitator with independence, sound judgement and credibility.

Internal facilitation can also be effective, particularly when the chair or lead director has established trusted relationships with individual directors. Direct conversations create opportunities to explore feedback, discuss specific examples and provide meaningful coaching. Some directors we spoke with also highlighted the value of periodically introducing an external facilitator to bring a fresh perspective and help ensure feedback is gathered and communicated objectively.

Ultimately, effectiveness depends less on whether the process is conducted internally or externally than on the facilitator’s candor, the quality of board relationships and the care taken to gather and deliver feedback.

From Assessment to Action

Collecting feedback is only one part of an effective assessment process. Its value depends on how the findings are used.

For board chairs and lead directors, peer assessments can inform conversations about individual contributions, development opportunities and areas for support, while revealing broader patterns affecting board discussions and decision-making.

Feedback should be specific enough to support meaningful action, with clear examples of strengths and opportunities for improvement rather than general observations.

Boards should also establish how feedback will be collected, summarized and shared, and who will have access to the results. Whether communicated directly to individual directors or through anonymized themes, the approach should align with the process’s objectives.

Findings may inform director development, succession planning and board refreshment, but should not be used to justify a predetermined outcome for an individual director.

 

Without a clear plan to translate feedback into action, assessments risk becoming an administrative exercise rather than an investment in board effectiveness.

A Measured Approach to Implementation

The findings do not suggest that every board needs formal peer-to-peer assessments. For some high-functioning boards, existing evaluations and regular conversations between directors and board leadership may provide sufficient insight into individual contributions.

For others, a more structured process may help address gaps in feedback, support director development or respond to changes in board composition and dynamics.

Boards considering their approach may wish to start with four practical questions:

  • What are we trying to achieve? Clarify whether the priority is director development, improved board dynamics, individual accountability and/or a better understanding of board composition.
  • What does success look like? Establish how the process should improve feedback, strengthen individual contributions or support broader board effectiveness.
  • What approach best fits our culture? Consider whether chair-led conversations, an external facilitator or a combination of methods would be most effective.
  • How will feedback be used? Agree on confidentiality, communication and follow-up before the process begins, ensuring directors understand how the information will inform development and governance decisions.

Boards not yet ready to introduce formal peer assessments can also build on existing practices. A brief questionnaire completed before annual one-on-one conversations with the lead director or chair could invite directors to share specific observations about their colleagues’ strengths and opportunities for improvement. This would provide more focused input for individual conversations without requiring a separate, fully developed process.

Such an approach can also help build trust before a board considers a more formal model.

Strengthening Board Effectiveness Over Time

Every board has a distinct culture, context and set of priorities. Peer-to-peer assessments are not necessary for every board, but when aligned with clear objectives and implemented thoughtfully, they can offer valuable insight into individual contributions and collective effectiveness.

As boards revisit their assessment practices, two questions provide a useful starting point: What are we looking to achieve, and what does success look like? The answers should guide the approach, ensuring the process reflects the board’s needs and supports its continued effectiveness.

____________________________________________________

Get in touch. Follow the links below to learn more, or connect directly with our dedicated executive and board search and leadership advisory experts at your local  Odgers office here.

Follow us

Join us on our social media channels and see how we’re addressing today’s biggest issues.

Find a consultant [[ Scroll to top ]]