The board's most consequential decision
Appointing a chief executive is the single most consequential decision a board will make. It shapes strategy, culture, risk appetite and shareholder value for years, yet many boards still treat succession as an event rather than a discipline. The question is often only asked in earnest when an incumbent signals departure, falls ill or is asked to leave.
By then, the board's options have narrowed. Internal candidates may not be ready, external searches are compressed into weeks rather than months, and the organisation reads the scramble as a signal of instability.
The boards that handle succession well share one trait: they own it continuously. They treat CEO succession as a standing governance responsibility, revisited every year, informed by objective evidence and insulated from the preferences of any single individual, including the sitting CEO.
“The boards that get caught out are rarely negligent; they are comfortable. When the CEO is performing well, succession feels like next year’s conversation. The best chairs I work with put it on the agenda precisely when things are going well, because that is when the board has the most options and the least pressure.”
Governance: who owns succession
The first governance principle is simple: CEO succession belongs to the board, not to the CEO. Responsibility for board and senior appointments, and for orderly succession, sits squarely with the board and its nomination committee. In regulated sectors such as financial services, the Central Bank of Ireland expects boards to demonstrate that succession for key roles is planned, documented and tested.
“In financial services, the regulator will ask not only whether you have a succession plan but whether you have tested it. A board should be able to show who steps in tomorrow morning, and how that person would get through fitness and probity approval without leaving a gap at the top.”
In practice, that ownership has three layers.
- The full board holds ultimate accountability. It approves the succession framework, agrees the profile of the future CEO in light of strategy, and makes the final appointment.
- The nomination committee does the sustained work. It maintains the succession plan, oversees the development of internal candidates, commissions external benchmarking and reports to the board at least annually.
- The chair leads the process and manages its most delicate relationship: the one with the incumbent CEO.
The incumbent's role deserves particular care. A good CEO should develop talent beneath them and contribute insight on potential successors. But a CEO who controls the process can, consciously or not, favour candidates in their own image, block strong rivals or delay their own departure. Best practice gives the CEO a voice, not a vote. When Kerry Group named Edmond Scanlon as its next chief executive in 2017, the process was overseen by the nomination committee under the chairman, and the successor chosen did not report directly to the outgoing CEO. The board, not the incumbent, made the call.
“The most delicate conversation in any succession is between the chair and the sitting CEO. A strong CEO will want to shape what comes next, and they should, but the board has to hold the pen. Settling that early saves a great deal of friction later.”
Good governance also means planning for three distinct scenarios, each with its own timeline.
- Emergency succession — an interim arrangement that can be activated within days if the CEO is suddenly unable to continue.
- Planned succession — a structured transition, typically over two to three years, aligned to the end of a CEO's natural tenure.
- Strategic succession — a change triggered by a shift in strategy, ownership or performance, where the board concludes a different kind of leader is needed.
When an independent director steps in. In an emergency, or where internal candidates are not yet ready, one option is for an independent non-executive director to step into the CEO role, usually on an interim basis and occasionally permanently. It can be the fastest and most stabilising choice available. An INED already knows the strategy, the board, the risks and the senior team, and their appointment reassures investors, staff and regulators that the business is in safe hands.
The move carries real governance consequences, though, and boards should think them through in advance rather than in the moment. The director gives up their independence on taking an executive role and will not regain it quickly, so they must step off the nomination, audit and remuneration committees, and the board may need to rebalance its composition. In regulated sectors, the appointment will typically need regulatory approval before the director can act. Above all, the board must be clear from the outset whether the interim CEO is a candidate for the permanent role. If they are, they cannot also help shape the succession process; if they are not, saying so publicly protects the integrity of the search and the confidence of internal candidates.
Best practice is to agree in the emergency succession plan which director could step in, for how long and on what terms, so that if the moment comes the board is executing a decision rather than improvising one.
In Part 2, we look at what best-in-class succession planning looks like, how evidence-based assessment strengthens the board’s decision, and the pitfalls to avoid.