⚠"
en | IE
OBSERVE Magazine

Subscribe to our global newsletter to discover our latest insights, opinions and featured articles.

The Board's Role in CEO Succession – Part 2

4 min read

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

In Part 1, we set out why CEO succession is the board’s most consequential decision and who should own it. Here we turn to what good practice looks like.

What best-in-class succession planning looks like

The strongest succession processes share six characteristics.

1. They start with strategy, not people. Before discussing names, the board agrees what the organisation will need from its next CEO over a five-to-ten-year horizon. A business facing transformation, international expansion or a regulatory reset needs a different leader from one consolidating a strong market position. This becomes a written success profile: the experiences, capabilities and leadership qualities the role will demand.

A good success profile is short, specific and agreed by the whole board. It typically covers four areas:

  • Strategic context. The three to five priorities the next CEO must deliver, and the scale, complexity and ownership of the business they will lead.
  • Experience. The career exposure that genuinely matters: leading a transformation, P&L ownership at a comparable scale, international or regulated-sector experience, or working with a PE or public-market shareholder base.
  • Leadership capabilities. The competencies the role demands, such as strategic judgement, building and leading a senior team, stakeholder and investor engagement, and resilience under pressure.
  • Personal qualities and culture. Values, motivation and leadership style, including what the organisation needs to change as well as what it must preserve.

The profile should be explicit about trade-offs and become the single yardstick against which every candidate, internal or external, is measured.

2. They build a genuine pipeline. Leading boards identify a small pool of internal candidates three to five years out, and invest deliberately in closing potential gaps through stretch roles, board exposure, mentoring and external coaching. Readiness is assessed honestly as "ready now", "ready in one to two years" or "ready in three or more".

“Most internal candidates don’t fall short on ability; they fall short on leadership capability. The step change needed to lead strategically and act as an ambassador for the organisation, both internally and externally can be daunting. This capability gap closes when structured development plans give them those experiences deliberately, years before the decision, rather than hoping they pick them up along the way.”

Ruth Likely Principal

Kerry shows what that investment looks like. Scanlon joined the group's graduate programme in 1996 and, over two decades, moved through finance, M&A in the Americas, global divisional leadership, China and finally the leadership of Asia-Pacific. By the time the board appointed him Chief Executive Designate, seven months ahead of the handover, the chairman could say plainly that the company had the talent it needed internally.

3. They benchmark against the market. Even when an internal appointment is likely, best practice tests internal candidates against external talent. This protects the board from insularity, strengthens the eventual appointee's mandate and satisfies stakeholders that the choice was rigorous.

The role of executive search. A specialist search firm brings an independent, market-wide view the board cannot generate on its own. It tests the success profile against what the market can realistically offer, benchmarks internal candidates against credible external leaders and reaches talent that would never respond to an advertisement. Because the firm reports to the chair or nomination committee rather than the CEO, it also reinforces the board's ownership of the process. The most valuable relationships are long-term: a firm engaged two or three years before a transition can help shape the profile, map the market, assess internal candidates and run a discreet search when the time comes, rather than being briefed in a hurry once a vacancy is announced.

“The searches that serve boards best are the ones where we have been part of the conversation for two or three years. By the time a vacancy is announced, we already understand the strategy, the internal candidates and who in the market is genuinely available. That is a very different starting point from a cold brief.”

Damian Ringwood Partner, Head of Board Practice and Head of Financial Services Practice

Glanbia shows how internal development and external benchmarking work together. When Siobhán Talbot, then Group Finance Director, succeeded John Moloney in 2013, Hugh McGuire joined the board at the same time, giving him board exposure a decade before he would need it. When Talbot retired in 2023, McGuire was the natural successor, yet the nomination and governance committee still ran an extensive selection process with the support of an executive search firm before confirming him. Two consecutive internal appointments, the second still benchmarked against the market, is what a mature succession culture looks like.

4. They get to know candidates directly. Non-executive directors should see potential successors present to the board, lead strategy sessions and engage informally. A board that meets candidates only in a final interview is choosing on very thin evidence.

5. They review the plan every year. Succession is a standing agenda item for the nomination committee, with an annual report to the full board on pipeline strength, development progress and emergency cover.

6. They map the market early. Market mapping identifies the leaders, inside and outside the sector, who could credibly step into the role over the next few years. Ideally commissioned by the nomination committee two to three years before an expected transition, a map shows the board the real depth and likely availability of external talent. It sharpens the success profile, gives a genuine benchmark for internal candidates and means an external search starts from knowledge rather than from scratch. Because availability changes quickly, the map should be refreshed every year or two.

Should directors meet people on the map? Selectively, yes. Once the map is complete, it is good practice for the chair, often with the nomination committee chair or another independent non-executive director, to meet a small number of the strongest external names informally, usually arranged through the search firm. These are exploratory conversations, not interviews: no role is offered and confidentiality on both sides is essential, particularly where candidates are serving CEOs or the incumbent's departure is not yet public. Handled well, they build relationships, test interest and give directors first-hand evidence. Handled carelessly, they can leak, unsettle the incumbent or raise expectations the board cannot meet, so they should be few, deliberate and coordinated by the chair.

“Some of the most valuable meetings I arrange are a quiet coffee between a chair and a serving CEO elsewhere, with no role on the table. Nothing is promised, but both sides learn a great deal, and when the moment comes the board is not meeting a stranger.”

Damian Ringwood Partner, Head of Board Practice and Head of Financial Services Practice

Replacing opinion with evidence: the role of LeaderFit™

The weakest point in most succession processes is assessment. Boards rely heavily on track record, interview performance and the views of those who have worked alongside a candidate. All are useful, but each is vulnerable to bias. Past success in one context does not guarantee success in a larger, more ambiguous role. Strong interviewees are not always strong leaders. And familiarity can work for or against an internal candidate in ways that have little to do with capability.

“The most useful feedback assessment gives an internal candidate is an honest picture early enough to act on. Being told you are ‘ready in two years’ only means something if it comes with a clear plan for getting there, in a way that holds you accountable .”

Ruth Likely Principal

Common pitfalls, and a closing thought

Even well-intentioned boards fall into familiar traps. They defer the conversation because the current CEO is performing well. They hire a successor who mirrors the outgoing leader rather than the future strategy. They neglect emergency cover. Or they manage the transition poorly, leaving the new CEO without clear authority while the predecessor lingers in an ambiguous role. Each of these is avoidable with the same remedy: treat succession as continuous, board-owned and evidence-led.

CRH offers a clean model of how to avoid the last of these. In September 2024 it announced that Jim Mintern, its CFO and a board director since 2021, would succeed Albert Manifold at the year end. Manifold stepped down from the board on the same day he handed over his executive responsibilities, and stayed on only as an advisor for 12 months. The chair framed the outcome as the result of the board's significant focus on succession planning throughout the group: succession treated as a board discipline, not a single event.

CEO succession is ultimately a test of a board's stewardship. Done well, it delivers more than a strong appointment. It builds leadership depth across the organisation, reassures investors and staff, and protects the board's own credibility. The boards that get it right start early, stay disciplined and make sure that when the moment comes, the decision rests on rigorous evidence rather than instinct alone.

“A board’s stewardship is judged less by the CEO it appoints, than by whether it gave itself a real choice. Succession done well means choosing between strong options, not settling for the only one available.”

Damian Ringwood Partner, Head of Board Practice and Head of Financial Services Practice
Find a consultant [[ Scroll to top ]]